Login  |  View Cart  |  Search

Learning from Indigenous Restorative Justice

Learning from Indigenous Restorative Justice
Deanna VanBuren - Thu Feb 23, 2012 @ 12:51PM
Comments: 10


Restorative justice is often  perceived as something new age but its roots go much further back than our punitive model. The emergence of restorative practices in places such as the United States, New Zealand and Rwanda are coming from ancient ways of dealing with harm in tribal communities long before due process. Therefore it seems logical when developing a contemporary vision for restorative infrastructures to understand the characteristics of indigenous dwellings for restorative justice and how they differ from our punitive model. The next few blogs will explore some of these qualities and explore endeavors by other organizations to harness this knowledge and incorporate it into contemporary life.

To start, the most  poignant characteristic of indigenous restorative architecture can often be the high levels of transparency. In the African South African traditions restorative justice circles were held under sacred trees where all could see; shaded but open. In Liberia the space for greeting, resolutions and discussion occurs in Palaver Huts. These spaces  are composed of only four posts, a thatched roof and are open on all sides. In modern day Rwanda, Gacaca courts occur outside in fields, plazas and civic spaces that merely provide adequate space for the volume of people.

palava_hut.jpg

Liberian Palaver Hut

In our punitive justice system we are told that it too is intended to be a transparent process that requires civic engagement to function. However when we look at the opaque exterior of the courthouse and the secure barrier to entry there is an obvious visual and physical impenetrability that is misaligned with the desire to present it as such.  Architects have attempted to diminish the negative impact of the secure and private program requirements but they are often fighting an up-hill battle.

004_impene_vs_porous.jpg 

As we envision the processes and activities within a modern day restorative justice center there are no judges, juries or lawyers. There are no antagonistic proceedings related to guilt or innocence as the perpetrator takes responsibilities for his or her actions, thereby reducing security measures. Community engagement is not one of duty but of personal connectivity as they are all directly related to those taking part in the discussions. The processes themselves permeate multiple layers of society as many forms of conflict resolution are taking place. The potential is that more members of the community will be coming to the center more frequently. This depth of service along with the reduction in program and security means that the Restorative Justice Center can and must have a high level of visual and physical porosity in the building envelope. Even those spaces that require greater levels of privacy should be able to provide a connection to the outdoors and activity beyond at eye level.

I believe that the lack of accessibility in our punitive model (along with the last chat about bulk and size) is one of the strongest points of departure for the restorative justice center.  If we are open to learning from indigenous restorative spaces I believe we can help new justice architecture to align itself with the values it is based on in a way the punitive model has been unable to sustain. Every time I look at these architectural typologies I can see a clear example of how what we value is what manifests.

 

Deanna VanBuren is the principal and founder of FOURM design studio in Oakland California.

Her practice specializes in designing for alternatives to incarceration. She is currently on the national board of Architects Designers Planners for Social Responsibility. 

 

Comments: 10

Comments

1. pennsy   |   Wed Jun 05, 2013 @ 04:11AM

Now people help it become possible for us to recognise and implement the style. Thanks for that write-up. I will be content to come across the known method of writing the write-up. http://kidsandteensarticles.info

2. home furniture ideas  |  my website   |   Fri Jun 07, 2013 @ 05:00AM

Treat your pet for fleas. If you don't, the pet will jump on the furniture and get new fleas on it that will multiply and cause a new infestation. You can get a flea treatment from your vet or use an over-the-counter flea treatment.
http://www.homefurnitureideas.eu

3. motor bike training  |  my website   |   Fri Jun 07, 2013 @ 05:00AM

The off road training involves an introduction to the main parts of the bike and how everything works, and if you're using a manual the gears and the clutch are introduced.
http://www.motorbiketraining.eu

4. food hygiene  |  my website   |   Fri Jun 07, 2013 @ 05:01AM

Touching face, hair, other parts of one's body are cause for hand hygiene in food environments. Touching anything deemed to be contaminated in health care as well as those sources listed in the earlier sentence are cause for hand hygiene.
http://www.foodhygiene.eu

5. beauty advice  |  my website   |   Fri Jun 07, 2013 @ 05:01AM

Some of the popular beauty tips for teenage girls are not based on any factual evidence but rather hearsay passed down from one generation to another
http://www.beautyadvice.eu

6. home security tips  |  my website   |   Fri Jun 07, 2013 @ 05:02AM

Very innovative technologies here. I like the idea of remote control through a cell phone, especially when integrated to the level of remote locks, lighting, and plug adapters. The sprinkler system idea is also intriguing.
http://www.homesecuritytips.eu

7. tompal   |   Tue Jun 11, 2013 @ 06:46AM

Restorative justice was the modus operandi in the earlier days. It provided for a transparency in the justice system where the public too had a say in the matters concerning them. One of the advantages was the feeling of oneness among the tribe.<a href="http://www.accountantco.com">www.accountantco.com</a>

8. saree blouse shopping  |  my website   |   Wed Jul 10, 2013 @ 12:04AM

Let him that hath no power of patience retire within himself, though even there he will have to put up with himself.

10. James Kyron   |   Mon Aug 12, 2013 @ 12:42PM

When we communicate, the vocabulary we use is really on part of the story and unconsciously we will be paying a huge amount of attention to more subtle body language cues.
Basketball training equipment - http://basketballtrainingpro.com/basketball-training-equipment/